Spare Me? Not So Fast

Almost a third of new vehicles no longer come with a spare tire.

by on Oct.19, 2017

Some manufacturers have eliminated the spare tire in favor of run-flat tires, such as in the Lexus LC 500.

There are few things more frustrating than being stuck on the side of the road with a flat tire – unless, that is, you also don’t have a spare.

In an effort to reduce weight, improve fuel economy and, yes, in some cases to save money, automakers have been cutting back the number of models equipped with spare tires, though they also note that they’re doing so on products like the new Lexus LC 500 sports coupe in order to give owners more cargo space.

Beyond the Headlines!

The silver lining is that today’s tires tend to be more rugged and reliable, and many vehicles are now equipped with run-flat tires that are designed to keep going for as much as 50 miles if they lose air pressure, enough to get to a service station for a repair or replacement, the manufacturers claim.

“Having a flat tire can be a nuisance for drivers, but not having a spare could put them in an even more aggravating situation,” said John Nielsen, managing director of Automotive Engineering and Repair for AAA. “This can turn the relatively routine process of changing a tire at the roadside into an inconvenient and costly situation that requires a tow to a repair facility.”

(Tesla caves to German workers’ salary demands. For the story, Click Here.)

According to AAA, 28% of the vehicles sold during the 2017 model-year skipped the spare, whether a conventional full-size replacement or a mini-spare. That’s actually a sign that the shift from spare-less vehicles may be winding down, at least in part due to widespread consumer concerns about the practice. During the 2015 model-year, the organization noted, 35% of new vehicles came without a spare.

The Lexus LC 500 is one of many vehicles using run-flat tires.

But don’t expect the spare to make a complete return, manufacturers stress, and for a variety of reasons. This is true in many compact cars, especially sports cars like the Lexus LC 500. That new sports coupe has almost no space to put a spare and even with a mini a motorist would be hard-pressed to find room for a couple bags of groceries.

Even on larger vehicles, manufacturers are being forced to cope with increasingly stringent new emissions and mileage regulations. One of the best ways to do so is by cutting mass. Even on a vehicle the size of a Honda Civic, the spare tire and jack can weigh in at over 25 pounds. On a large SUV the number can double.

One alternative is the run-flat tire. They use extra-thick, reinforced sidewalls that allow a motorist to keep going should they lose pressure, typically for at least 50 miles.

(Click Here for more about falling gas prices.)

Run-flats aren’t cheap to replace, and some motorists complain that they deliver a harsher ride than regular tires with more compliant – flexible – sidewalls. Newer run-flat designs have improved ride comfort, however.

The other alternative is a spare tire inflation kit. In some cases, that’s simply an air pump to fill back up a tire that’s simply lost some pressure. But the most common approach also introduces some form of foam sealer that closes up a nail or other puncture wound to the tire.

Nonetheless, “With low-profile tires and the elimination of a spare tire, many newer vehicles are especially vulnerable to roadside tire trouble,” Nielsen said. “AAA urges drivers to make it a priority to check their vehicle’s equipment and know what to do if faced with a flat tire.”

The organization offers a handful of tips for motorists, especially those buying a new or used model:

  • Check to see if it comes with a spare and, if not, what alternative it offers;
  • Read the instructions before you have a flat so you’ll have at least an idea what to do in such an emergency;
  • Inspect all of your tires – including the spare, if you have one – to make sure they are in good condition and properly inflated. Under-inflated tires reduce fuel economy and are more prone to premature wear and failure;
  • Check expiration dates if you have an inflator kit. The foam cans typically need to be replaced every four to eight years.

Not surprisingly, AAA also recommends signing up for a roadside service plan – though it is just one of many vendors and a number of new vehicles include roadside service in their warranty coverage.

(To see more about the secrets revealed from the leak of the 2018 Jeep Wrangler user guide, Click Here.)

Last year alone, AAA said, it helped 450,000 U.S. motorists who didn’t have a spare. It also had to help out a number of drivers who did have one but who didn’t know how to change out a flat. A previous AAA study found that 20% of American drivers, about 39 million all told, don’t know how to change a tire.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , ,

One Response to “Spare Me? Not So Fast”

  1. Tom Morales says:

    We took our 2011 BMW 535xi on a road trip, and tore a sidewall in a pothole. This was on an Easter Sunday. The car has low-profile, high-performance run-flat tires.

    The good news was that we were in a major city (Oakland CA). The next day, we could track down a replacement tire and, by that evening, we were back in business, though one-day late on our trip schedule.

    Had we been half-way to nowhere (which, if you take long road trips, will be surprising frequently), it could easily be more than 50 miles (the run-flat range) to the nearest backwoods tire place. There, it could take you a week to get a replacement tire. (That’s how long it took to get replacements in the small city I live in.)

    Also, If you’ve taken long road trips, you will be aware that there are many long stretches of road with no cell phone service. Being in that situation with no full-size spare tire potentially disastrous.

    The bottom line: we no longer take our BMW on long road trips. It’s the best road car I’ve ever had, but it works only as long as all my tires are intact.